I agree with all of your assessments except one. I didn't find the movie particularly entertaining. Phoenix's portrayal was almost distracting while the time jumps and glaring omissions cut out what could have been very entertaining moments and basically neutered the story. After watching it, it's obvious that Scott intended to make a movie about Napoleon and Josephine primarily. Unfortunately, even that aspect fails as the viewer never truly understands why the relationship might be special or why we should care. Just my two cents!
To be fully honest, I was disappointed by the movie. Given my high expectations, Phoenix's performance was very underwhelming and unconvincing. But I'm just happy that pop culture is taking any interest at all in history; even that is an achievement of Napoleonic proportions!
Well, I under having to take liberties and condense the story, but they basically neutered it. It wasn't even a highlight real. I have no idea what Phoenix was doing. Lol
Yeah, I can't help but agree with you. But it's always easier to critique something than to create it, right? Film reviewers always have to keep this in mind.
Just seeing Napoleon's story played out on the big screen—with all those beautiful costumes, set designs, and A-list actors—that alone is just a magical experience. In spite of Phoenix's lackluster performance, I will freely add.
I agree. It was definitely a beautiful film. It's easy to fault them for the story I would have rather they told. I just can't help think of how incredible it could have been.
I feel the same way. But I'm very confident that more Napoleon movies/TV shows will follow up. If nothing else, Ridley Scott at least generated interest in the great Bonaparte!
I agree with all of your assessments except one. I didn't find the movie particularly entertaining. Phoenix's portrayal was almost distracting while the time jumps and glaring omissions cut out what could have been very entertaining moments and basically neutered the story. After watching it, it's obvious that Scott intended to make a movie about Napoleon and Josephine primarily. Unfortunately, even that aspect fails as the viewer never truly understands why the relationship might be special or why we should care. Just my two cents!
To be fully honest, I was disappointed by the movie. Given my high expectations, Phoenix's performance was very underwhelming and unconvincing. But I'm just happy that pop culture is taking any interest at all in history; even that is an achievement of Napoleonic proportions!
Well, I under having to take liberties and condense the story, but they basically neutered it. It wasn't even a highlight real. I have no idea what Phoenix was doing. Lol
Yeah, I can't help but agree with you. But it's always easier to critique something than to create it, right? Film reviewers always have to keep this in mind.
Just seeing Napoleon's story played out on the big screen—with all those beautiful costumes, set designs, and A-list actors—that alone is just a magical experience. In spite of Phoenix's lackluster performance, I will freely add.
I agree. It was definitely a beautiful film. It's easy to fault them for the story I would have rather they told. I just can't help think of how incredible it could have been.
I feel the same way. But I'm very confident that more Napoleon movies/TV shows will follow up. If nothing else, Ridley Scott at least generated interest in the great Bonaparte!